How to Accessorize the Butter Yellow Trend Like a Style Pro

Soft, sunny and effortlessly chic — butter yellow is the color trend brightening up everything from Pinterest boards (yes, it’s in the 2025 Palette!) to celebrity wardrobes. Spotted on Sabrina Carpenter, Timothée Chalamet and Kendall Jenner (to name a few), this creamy hue is clearly having a moment. But what jewelry pairs best with its golden glow? Whether you’re reaching for a linen sundress or a structured blazer, here’s how to style your jewelry to make the most of this buttery trend.

Contents show

1. Golden Hour

Let’s start with the basics—butter yellow and gold jewelry are a match made in tonal heaven. Yellow gold blends seamlessly with the soft warmth of the hue, creating a sunlit, monochromatic effect. Want to add a hint of romance? Opt for rose gold jewelry. The blush undertones add a soft contrast that enhances butter yellow’s creamy base without overpowering it.

Expert tip: Because butter yellow is so soft, lean into minimalistic gold jewelry instead of super chunky pieces. It keeps the look light, breezy and expensive — exactly how butter yellow feels.

Shop Gold Jewelry

2. Pearl Power

There’s something about pearls and butter yellow that feels downright poetic. Maybe it’s the classic-meets-modern energy or the way the creamy tones complement each other. Either way, white pearls bring a cool contrast to the warmth of yellow, while South Sea pearls—with their soft golden glow—amplify the richness of the shade.

Expert tip: When accessorizing with pearls, keep the look balanced by choosing delicate, understated pieces that enhance the butter yellow without clashing with it.

Shop Pearl Jewelry

3. Color Contrast

Butter yellow may be soft, but that doesn’t mean your jewelry has to be. Vibrant gemstones add dimension, personality and unexpected bursts of color that can either complement or contrast beautifully with this trend.

Citrines and yellow sapphires are great picks for those who want to fully lean in. They echo the hue while adding extra sparkle. Whereas, emeralds and peridots create a striking contrast that brings freshness and vibrancy to the look.

Want something delicate and romantic? Morganites and pink tourmalines are dreamy against butter yellow, creating an almost painterly palette.

Expert tip: If your butter yellow outfit is super simple (think minimalist dress or co-ord), pick jewelry in a bold color for that wow factor. But if your outfit already has ruffles, embroidery or a lot going on, keep your jewelry soft and tonal to stay chic, not clashing.

Shop Gemstone Jewelry

4. Diamond Details

Of course, we couldn’t talk about styling without a nod to diamonds. Butter yellow is an ideal canvas for their brilliance, especially when you play with tone. White diamonds offer a crisp, clean contrast. Whereas, coffee and yellow diamonds blend beautifully for a warm, golden-hour glow.

Expert tip: If your outfit feels soft and fluid, let your jewelry echo that mood. Look for pear or oval-shaped diamonds — they’re curvier, more fluid and they vibe better with the gentle, mellow feel of butter yellow.

Shop Diamond Jewelry

Frequently Asked Questions

1. Why is butter yellow trending?

Butter yellow’s soft, optimistic vibe and surprising versatility as a neutral alternative are key. Plus, major fashion houses and celebs are embracing its fresh appeal.

2. What colors pair well with butter yellow?

Neutrals like ivory and beige, warm metallics like gold and pastel shades such as powder blue, blush or lilac pair well by mirroring the softness of butter yellow. While contrast shades like navy, emerald green and deep plum add a bold effect.

3. What kind of jewelry goes with the butter yellow trend?

Think warm harmony with yellow and rose gold. Pearls offer classic contrast, while diamonds add subtle sparkle. Delicate styles often enhance butter yellow’s softness best.